Agents furious over government leasehold plans

A prominent agent is leading a backlash against the government’s controversial Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill. 

The Bill, coming before Parliament today, details landmark laws to end the 1,000-year-old leasehold system. Key measures include:

  • Capping ground rents at £250 a year in 2028: cuts bills for up to one million leaseholders and reduces ground rents to zero after 40 years;
  • Ending unfair threats to take away people’s homes: removes outdated powers that can put a leaseholder’s home at risk over relatively small unpaid bills, such as a disputed service charge and replaces them with a fairer, court-led system;
  • Capping rip-off admin fees: gives ministers powers to cap excessive permission and administration fees, like asking permission to keep a pet or replace a front door;
  • Banning leasehold for new flats and homes: makes Commonhold the standard for most new flats (with narrow exceptions like shared ownership), meaning buyers own their home outright forever and run their building jointly from day one;
  • Easier route to switch to Commonhold: drops the threshold for existing blocks to convert from 100% neighbour agreement down to 50% support, allowing non-consenting neighbours to remain on modified leases until they sell, so holdouts cannot block conversion for the rest of the building;
  • Ending so-called ‘fleecehold’ estate enforcement threats: protects people living on freehold housing estates from threats to take over their home over unpaid estate maintenance charges;
  • Unlocking cheaper, easier lease extensions and freehold purchases: fixes parts of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024. This will help homeowners buy 990-year lease extensions, stop them having to pay their landlord’s costs in most cases and will scrap marriage value, an additional cost faced by leaseholders with 80 years or less remaining on their leases;
  • Strengthening leaseholders’ right to request a gigabit broadband connection: helps more leaseholders access fast and reliable broadband, which landlords can currently ignore. In future, landlords will have to respond within set timeframes. 

Commonhold campaigners have demanded change for some years and the reform was a pledge in Labour’s 2024 election manifesto. 

But Simon Gerrard – chairman of the high profile independent Martin Gerrard Estate Agents in London – is unhappy.

He says: “The assumption is that the freeholders are acting inappropriately and that residents will always act appropriately. This is simply not the case.

“It would be wonderful if every single person living in the block committed to doing the best thing: paying charges on time and acting appropriately for the common building. But this rarely happens. 

“Commonhold is an opportunity that has been around for 20 years, with just a handful of use cases in the country – what does that tell you about how successful it is as a framework?”

His criticism is echoed by Kate Butler, Assistant Director of Policy at the fledgling property industry trade body called Real Estate:UK.

Describing the Bill’s proposals as “disappointing” she continues: “Reforms must fairly balance the rights of leaseholders and property investors. 

“A proposal that cuts across existing commercial arrangements, raises the risk premium attached to the UK, and undermines its investment reputation, at a time when the government is seeking to attract capital for its growth agenda, does not achieve this.

“Instead, the government must work towards a pragmatic solution that identifies and addresses the few ground rents that affect owner-occupier leaseholders, while preserving legitimate investments and the UK’s reputation as a place to invest.”

She adds that while her organisation supports the principle of Commonhold “the transition must be carefully phased and considered so that all parties, including leaseholders, conveyancers, lenders and managing agents, understand and are comfortable with the significant changes involved. These changes cannot be arbitrarily rushed.”

However Andrew Lloyd, managing director of conveyancing data firm Search Acumen, believes the changes could eventually improve buyer confidence especially for hard-to-sell flats.

He comments: “The biggest beneficiaries are flats currently suffering from escalating ground rents, short leases, expensive administration charges, and onerous permissions regimes.”

But like more critical property professionals, he admits transactions could become more complicated in the interim.

“For property lawyers, this is potentially one of the most consequential reforms since enfranchisement rights were expanded.”

Conveyancers will need to advise clients on commonhold conversions, ground rent restrictions and disputes between leaseholders. The changes could also lead to challenging valuation disagreements.

“Whenever legislation creates unknown future economics, lawyers become more cautious. That can slow transactions.”

–

Today’s proposals are not the end of the story and the government gives this timetable for future activity:

1 April 2027:
  • Stronger service charge rights and protections: leaseholders will have greater access to information about what they are paying for and how their building is managed, maintained, repaired and insured;
  • New rules on recovery of landlord litigation costs, meaning that leaseholders will no longer automatically be on the hook to pay these costs. Leaseholders will also be able to recover their litigation costs from landlords.
1 November 2027:
  • Clearer service charge bills: private landlords will have to provide standardised bills, annual reports and accounts showing what leaseholders are paying for;
  • Clearer administration charges: leaseholders will get better information about administration charges and how they are calculated;
  • More transparent building insurance: there will be clearer standardised information about insurance costs and new rules replacing percentage-based commissions with transparent payments for legitimate work.
1 November 2028:
  • Clearer service charge bills for social housing leaseholders: standardised bills, annual reports and accounts will also apply to social landlords.

Kindly shared by EstateAgentTODAY image courtesy of Adobe